Dorsal Augmentation Using Costal Cartilage: What Is the Best Way?

Article information

Clin Exp Otorhinolaryngol. 2019;12(4):327-328

Publication date (electronic) : 2019 September 4

doi : https://doi.org/10.21053/ceo.2019.01256

Yong Ju Jang

Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Asan Medical Center, University of Ulsan College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea

Received 2019 July 26; Accepted 2019 August 5.

The problematic aspect of dorsal augmentation is that the nasal dorsum is the broadest and the most prominent part of the nose; any minor imperfection is easily discernible by an observer. Furthermore, there is virtually no single ideal graft material and method for the nasal dorsum, free of aesthetic complication. Autologous costal cartilage has been advocated as the best material for dorsal augmentation by many prominent surgeons without strong evidence on literature. However, in the realworld practice, due to the difficulty in harvesting and usage as well as the high propensity to aesthetic complications, costal cartilage could not gain wide popularity as silicone implants, particularly in Asian regions.

Autologous costal cartilage can be used as a dorsal implant in various forms [1]. Traditionally, using it in mono-block carved implant form has been the most common and standard way of dorsal augmentation. If a surgeon is skillful and highly experienced with this approach, this would be an ideal option. This is because one can achieve substantial augmentation with adequate hardness and relatively good viability of the cartilage. However, there are potential problems with this approach. It is not easy to create an implant that has a natural shape and a smooth surface. Besides, complications such as warping, graft movability, and visible contour irregularity continue to be bothering problems [2]. To overcome the inherent disadvantage of solid block costal cartilage for dorsal augmentation, we are witnessing a growing interest in using the costal cartilage in the diced form [3]. Diced cartilage for augmentation is relatively free from the risk of warping and displacement. Another advantage of dicing the cartilage is that surgeons can minimize the amount of cartilage harvested as they can maximize the use of even small remnant fragments of the cartilage after septal reinforcement and tip work, thus not necessitating the harvest of a very long and straight piece of costal cartilage. Although diced cartilage is reported to have good viability and improved chondrocyte survival, the critical weakness of this material is its potential for resorption and difficulty in delivering to the nasal dorsum. In order to ease delivery, dorsal augmentation using diced cartilage is generally accompanied by wrapping with fascia, Surgicel, and Alloderm [3-5]. Another way of using diced cartilage is to make it semi-solid by using fibrin glue [6]. Unlike fascia wrapped diced cartilage, this technique may display increased chance of migration of fragments or visible contour of the cartilage piece, especially through the thin skin. Grafting technique using diced cartilage combined with autologous tissue glue (platelet-rich plasma plus fibrin glue) has also been introduced recently [7]. The use of free diced cartilage without a wrapping material is another option which is suitable for camouflage purpose and minor dorsal augmentation. The final shaping must depend on molding the dorsal contour with fingers and meticulous taping and splinting [8]. Taken together, the trend of dorsal augmentation using costal cartilage is being shifted to using diced cartilage, which calls for a further refinement by technical modification and evidence-based outcome researches.